You can determine the sex of your discus accurately by paying close attention to the fish during spawning. I have a 90g with 6 Discus. or fertilized eggs are desired. Is somewhat odd that there not eating the eggs once they go white, but the poor male is getting spousal abuse for something he did not do. We’ve known Rick and Amerie for ages. I am using a mix of R/O water and tap water, and running peat moss through the filter. I have managed to get a few wigglers, but they don't seem to be "sticking" to the breeding cone. As i write this my male PB is fertilizing the eggs laid by my BD. Please let me know what you all think. Tue Aug 30, 2011, 07:21 AM. ... laying took place but the male has not fertilized, I think n 7/8 months, I will ask the small local breeder who provided me. Try lowering your water hardness to around 100 to 200 microsiemens. Any help would be appreciated. 2. After a day you will see that the eggs are dark brown in color. Discus fish take care of their eggs Discus fish eggs. lane L, DNA ladder. It seems my female BD does a better job guarding the eggs than the other female, a red turq. I'm new to discus and have recently acquired a pair of red scribbelt stendkers. Is this because the male isn't fertilising them? Sorry to keep hornin in on your thread lora .......... but i guess we can learn together. One male takes turns fertilizing the eggs of alternating females on a weekly basis*w3. I thought I'd update my situation. There is a rule of thumb to follow. After a day or so all is well again. Having hard water in your discus breeding aquarium will cause the shell of the newly laid discus eggs to harden quickly. TABLE 1. Your breeding pair is getting sluggish and not fanning the eggs. AHHHH. I have a pair of turks that have been laying weekly for almost 2 months and the eggs turn white pretty quick. Otherwise, sexing even adult Discus (Symphysodon) is nigh on impossible, despite the claims of others. 4. The female Discus will swim over the spawning site and deposit her eggs in rows, and they male will swim behind her and promptly fertilize them. PDA. It is nearly impossible to distinguish male Discus from females. It will not be difficult to obtain the names of dealers and breeders, and importantly, the impression of others, as to their integrity. Fertilized eggs will hatch within 48 hours. Fertilization rates and viability at the age of 2 mo of F1 progenies from hybrid families of female H. diversicolor3 male H. discus discus. I put them in a breeding tank and will see how it goes. I have males that seem to be shooting blanks. As disappointing as it has been, I'm still determined to get a successful spawn from these two. WYSIWYG: this is a What You See Is What You Get item. If you have a discus lay eggs but the eggs never hatch there is a good chance that you have 2 female discus. 48 hours after being deposited, fertilized eggs on the other hand will begin showing wiggling fry tails. MIne spawned again Friday, but when I checked the eggs this morning they were all white. This is the best time to identify the exact gender of your discus. All my rams and discus have spawned in my tap water [7.6 ph /2-3 KH /9 GH with a TDS of 350+]. Hi all. Hard water or infertile male? Water parameters are not an issue, the problem is with the male. I wish to once again stress the importance of keeping your Discus in soft water. You must reduce the water changes to reduce the stimulation of spawning. If they are young discus, I would give them another chance before taking the eggs and hatching them yourself. View Full Version : Male not Fertilizing Eggs. They are spawning now in my tank and again the male is eating the eggs. Discus eggs, and other cichlid eggs, are typically a clear and/or slightly pink color when fertilized. 5. They don't last more than a day or two. At 11 cm he is not capable of fertilizing the eggs in any case. ... Discus Forums > The Amazon Tank > Breeding Basics > Male eating eggs as laid. You probabl;y do not need the DI part which is good as it is the most expensive and quickly exhausted resin in the system . On day 3, thay went white. ... Discus eating her own eggs .Male Discus eat. Our poultry expert will contact you soon. So you get this exact fish, and not a similar fish. You sure the water is not too hard? < The eggs should not need a water change for the three days it will take the eggs to hatch. 5 years ago. Some males will not fertilize … Nitrate 2.0, Nitrite 0, GH 7.5 Kh 4.0, Ph 6.8. After a day or so all is well again. Do small water changes when the fry are free swimming.-Chuck> urgent Discus fish laid eggs again. MIne spawned again Friday, but when I checked the eggs this morning they were all white. I have had successful spawns in regular tap water, which here is about 7.2, I guess I'll he'll have to practice some more. I wonder if the female thinks the male ate the eggs and is giving him heck for it. There are many myths out there regarding how to successfully sex discus, but the most reliable is to have a good look at the breeding tubes (and even this sometimes fools even the … My question is, will he ever get it right, or does he just need more practice. Re: How to Protect Discus Fish Eggs Shifting Discus Eggs To A New Tank II 9/22/11 THANKS Can I change water of tank in which the eggs are there? The softer water should give the male plenty of time to fertilize the spawn. If your water is hard then the eggs from a protective shell before the ***** from the male can fertilise them. Lower the water’s hardness to about 100 to 200 microsiemens. I am convinced they were hormoned (the red color disapeared after a few months) before I bought them and many have said that this can make them sterile. This makes it very difficult for the male discus to fertilize these eggs. Origin: The ancestors of this Discus lived in the Rainforests in the Amazon in South America, but this fish were raised on a famous fish farm. Your male is getting sluggish and not fertilising them/ not fertilising them soon enough. This makes it very difficult for the male discus to fertilize these eggs. Otherwise someone is going to have to explain him a thing or two ;) Nobody panic, what I mean is If you have a proven male you can place in the tank with the couple maybe a little bit of jealousy is the key here!:D. I feel better knowing there are other people out there with the same problem, learning from each other is what this forum is all about. Maximum Size: In aquariums Discus can grow to be about … Fertilized eggs will stay the same color as they were laid regardless of water parameters. 09-10-2006, 09:24 AM. 6. Well I have a male and female discus and the female have just spawned on the filter but the Male just seems to go nowhere near the eggs and the female just keeps fanning them. When I put the cone back in the tank, they start fighting. Lora. The advantage of this method is that eggs from a large number of females can be fertilized as one testis of a mature male can easily fertilize the eggs of 10-15 females.The sperm (diluted or non-diluted) is added to the stripped eggs, and the eggs fertilized by adding an equal volume of clean water. Water Parameters plays their role after 24 -72 hours. I have a pair of Snow Whites that spawn on a regular basis, at least 8 times now, the problem is the male is not fertilizing the eggs, he makes the motions, but the eggs turn white. He seems not to be attempting to fertilise them at all, instead causally pecking away at the eggs as the female continues to deposit. Discus are quite difficult to care for and breed, and you may not achieve a high survival rate for the young on your first attempt. The parenting Discus will even pick off and consume the unfertilized eggs to eliminate the chance of disease spreading to healthy eggs. It is not uncommon for two young females to pair up together, so don’t assume just because two of your young fish are together and one is laying eggs, one is a female and the other a male. PDA. Too much ammonia, nitrite or nitrate. Don't be surprised to find a kindred spirit in your own backyard; the cult of the Discus is far reaching! I'm curious to see how the eggs do, that will answer some of my questions as far as water parameters. The male looks as if he is fertilizing the eggs, but they still turn white, which makes me think he's not doing his job. Name: Discus Family: Cichlidae Size: 6 inches Care Level: High maintenance Minimum Tank Size: 3 feet (36 inches) Temperature: 25 to 28 degrees Celsius Water Conditions: Soft to medium (4.0 to 7.0 pH) Diet: Omnivorous Tank Size: 25 gallons Temperament:Highly social A few days before she lays her eggs, the female develops a short tube, or ovipositor, just in front of her anal fin. This means that the eggs are fertilized, between the eggs there can also be some white ones, which indicates that they are not fertilized, the parents will remove the unfertilized eggs themselves. As evident, the fish that lays eggs is the female, while the one that goes over the eggs to fertilize them is the male. It is my experience that these males tend to have a lower fertility rate. There are invariably some Discus fanciers in the group; perhaps even a breeder or two. check out the. MS, male parent-specific band; N, nonparent locus band; P, polymorphic locus band. Ed13, the Discus do not hurt each other when they fight, if they did, I would separate them. Theoretically speaking, male Discus are duller in color and have more patterns on them than the female. An accurate way of determining their sex, however, is when they spawn. I wonder if the female thinks the male ate the eggs and is giving him heck for it. The oxygen levels in your tank are low. Water parameters are not an issue, the problem is with the male. 1. The fish that lays eggs is obviously the female. When I had an Angelfish pair lay eggs...the first time they ate the eggs, so when next time they laid the eggs I removed the slate an put it in a seperate tank where I put a bubble stream of air and I removed any white eggs...I did loose a great percentage of the eggs, but did get many to hatch...My point being if the parent fish are not properly caring for the eggs...(stay close and … Unfertilized eggs or defected eggs will turn white within 24 hours. Unfortunately, not all eggs in an incubator will survive the incubation process - no … It is also important to note that if you see your Discus laying eggs, but they do not hatch, this means you have no male Discus … No. Could the GH be the problem? Conduct an egg to young 5-6 cm fry is a little bit more complex. Discus is not a very easy fish to keep, and breeding them in aquariums is even harder. When I put the cone back in the tank, they start fighting. The female isn't agressive towards the male or anything. This was spawn number 9. After a day or so all is well again. The male then swims over the eggs to fertilize them. It's quite funny to watch. As spawning time approaches, the female’s abdomen becomes slightly enlarged because of the eggs she is carrying. A less expensive alternative to getting a discus pair is to purchase 12 or more of the same discus strain/color when they are young. Try lowering your water hardness to around 100 to 200 microsiemens. If they have not been eaten by other inhabitants of the aquarium, unfertilized Scalare eggs will be attacked by fungus and start looking very fuzzy after roughly 48 hours. This pair has now spawned at least 30 times. Some males only make the run after every two or three egg laying runs. Sexual differences in Discus (Symphysodon) It is reasonably easy to distinguish the sex of the adult Discus (Symphysodon) only when the female is laying eggs and the male is fertilizing them. Aquarium size for Discus (Symphysodon) Miffy moo. Cage, you are welcome to "horn in" anytime. One feature not found in most other aquarium species is the young fish's instinct to feed from the parents' skin, making them easier to care for if you are willing to leave the two generations in the same tank. The softer water should give the male plenty of time to fertilize the spawn. Mine don't eat the eggs, so I take the breeding cone out and scrub it with an old toothbrush to clean off the eggs. Im not sure if its the water or not for mine but should know soon. Some people market Discus as small as 2 cm (0.8 in); even an expert is hard press… reply #3. dannypj. View Full Version : Male eating eggs as laid. My question is, will he ever get it right, or does he just need more practice. It's quite funny to watch. SimplyDiscus > Main Discus Topics > Breeding Discus > Male not Fertilizing Eggs. I have a pair of Snow Whites that spawn on a regular basis, at least 8 times now, the problem is the male is not fertilizing the eggs, he makes the motions, but the eggs turn white. A good source of Discus can often be located through one's local aquarium society. Their last spawn, last week they got to hour 50 before eating the eggs. I have a pair of Red Turquoise that have recently paired up and have spawned twice in the community tank. I hate to go here, but perhaps your male is sterile! Make sure you have a pair of male and a female instead of pair of same sex. Click here to see several more pictures of the Royal Purple Discus . Mine don't eat the eggs, so I take the breeding cone out and scrub it with an old toothbrush to clean off the eggs. Meta Discuss the workings and policies of this site ... an egg only becomes a living being, and thus forbidden to eat, if it's been fertilized. If your discus spawns are hatching at low rates, the first thing you should do is make your tank’s water softer. Female fish would have a fatter abdomen during pregnancy and it will lay eggs later. In most respects, Discus Fish spawn like angelfish. Sorry to keep hornin in on your thread lora .......... but i guess we can learn together. 3. Returns, Replacements, Refunds & Warranties. This was spawn number 9. I tested their breeding tank water and here are the parameters. try 1 drop of 37% formaldahyde per gal of water! I have put the pair back in to the community tank, I wanted them to take a break from spawning for a while, but they were doing the "dance" today. Hard water in your breeding aquarium will cause the shell of freshly laid discus eggs to harden too fast, and then the male discus won’t be able to fertilize the eggs. Are you able to chat lhforbes12? The next step is cleaning an area on which to deposit and fertilize their eggs. Discus Strain Catalogue ( member submitted-- Strains galore! It's quite funny to watch. How to encourage discus to lay eggs. I have already lost 5 batches of eggs as they go white and the female just eats them. This is Nicole is your not able I have sent you a message. When science and magic collide, the story begins. You are doing water changes with colder water and higher pH which is stimulating the female to spawn, but she should not be laying eggs at 11 cm she should still be eating. When I put the cone back in the tank, they start fighting. The water in thier tank is exactly the smae as other pairs that are getting a good hatch rate. I wonder if the female thinks the male ate the eggs and is giving him heck for it. Having hard water in your discus breeding aquarium will cause the shell of the newly laid discus eggs to harden quickly. Mine don't eat the eggs, so I take the breeding cone out and scrub it with an old toothbrush to clean off the eggs. Do you think I have an infertile male, or should I let them keep trying? lora. . Please let me know what you all think. ), First Annual Discus Hobbyist Challenge (2008), Second Annual Discus Hobbyist Challenge (2009), Third Annual Discus Hobbyist Challenge (2012), Third Annual Hobbyists Contests 2012: Discussions and Information, Kingdom Come Discus - Wilmore, Kentucky, USA, Homesteader (It's Your World Within Our World), Adult Discus Show Tank (afriend) - NW Arkansas, Bison's Open Range (Kraig Koontz) - Kentucky, Brew's World (brewmaster15) - Connecticut, Coralbandit's Fish Foom - (coralbandit) - Saratoga NY, Discus Living with the OC (Orange Crush) - USA, Keith's Korner (Keith Perkins) - Janesville, Wisconsin, Larry's Loft (Larry208) - Austerlitz, New York, Len's Place (Len) - Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada, Mishka's House of Geh-Tao (chaoslite) - Van Nuys, California, Pat's Crow Nest (Second Hand Pat) - Central Florida, Phil's Fish Fam (Phil4Discus) - Houston, Texas, Scott's Fortress of Disc-i-tude - (CCC) - Scott Taylor in SLO county, CA, The Clean House of Turqs (rickztahone) - Pacoima, California, The Strudel Bakery (pastry) - Charleston, SC, Tobi's 'Wild' Discus Adventures - (Swedgin) - Dubai, UAE, Tony's Fishy iSpace (MKD aka MadDiscus) - SoCal/Garden Grove, California, Chicago Discus (Josie Christopher / Miranda Miller) - Chicago, Illinois, CTDiscus.com (Brewmaster15) - Northford, Connecticut, DiscusDirectOnline (Tyrone Gillespie) Oceanside, California, DiscusForrest (Breeder & Exporter) - Johor, Malaysia, Delightful Designs Discus Cones (Barb Odgers) - North Carolina, Dennis' Discus Fish (Dennis Velkov) - Bowling Green Ohio, Flow Tamer Spraybars(Walt Landru, Greenwood Lake , NY), Golden State Discus (Doug and Lynda Warner)-Rocklin,California, Kenny's Discus (Kenny Cheung) - Daly City, California, SNOOKN21's Wild Discus/Freshwater Tropicals (John) - Fort Myers, Florida, Winnie's Discus (Ceyhun,Breeder/Owner) -Jackson Heights, NY, If this is your first visit, be sure to View Full Version : Male not Fertilizing Eggs. my eggs were good for 2 days. As the topic says I am watching my pair spawn again and the male is not fertilizing the eggs just following behind very closely and having a feast. Hoping you have time to answer some questions. If the eggs are not fertilized, they will start turning white after approximately 24 hours. If they do not clean a spawning place, all the gesturing is just a dominance contest. Get discus eggs is not very hard. Both Discus will care for the eggs by constantly fanning them for aeration. Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.2 Copyright © 2021 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved. I measure TDS for this since GH and pH do not move the same and the test are far less accurate . When Discus lay eggs, the male should follow the female on a fertilizing run as soon as she does an egg laying run. The shop I go them from said they spawns in store and the male ate the eggs shortly after. I have a pair of Snow Whites that spawn on a regular basis, at least 8 times now, the problem is the male is not fertilizing the eggs, he makes the motions, but the eggs turn white. While the male discus will swim around the eggs in order to fertilize them and keep them safe. Does anyone have an opinion on this possibility? Do you think I have an infertile male, or should I let them keep trying?